Offline
The difference is that Brady can make every throw in the route tree. He also has intangibles. Brees throw plenty of checkdowns. Newton is a middle of the pack QB at best. The years have proven it so.Brady's been eating off these throws for years. We can't say he needs to make the smart play and then when its made nitpick and say well his % only increased because he threw dump downs.
The only thing I never get is why Cam's critiqued different than other Qbs(albeit this is how he won the MVP). A few season ago him, Rivers and Brady completed the highest percentage of throws 10-20 ft(intermediate) and most people still said he had to improve intermediate throws....