Chrissy Simms top 40 QB Ranking (Updates till completion) (1 Viewer)

[JackT.]

good to see the media is putting women in high ranking positions. finally.

 

[BreesusSaves]

Winston was on pace to throw 39 touchdowns last season. That would have placed him third overall in the league in 2021. If he picks up where he left off last season, and now he's got dramatically better weapons? I don't think it is unrealistic to expect him to throw 30 or more touchdowns. However the biggest thing I am hoping Winston maintains was his interception rate. He was on pace to throw just 8.5 interceptions last season. He was protecting the football and capitalizing on scoring opportunities. With this defense, that is all the QB has to do for them to make a serious run.

 

[Domeination]

There are two things that have huge impact on how he evaluates. He likes QBs who have big arms. And he likes WRs/CBs who can fly down the field. These aren't the only factors, obviously. But in his mind if there's a QB or WR who can do everything else at an elite level but they lack that one thing, he will always devalue them in relation to how others view that player. It's as simple as that.

So he should love Jameis, then, no?

 

[NOLA or bust]

Dudes a hack. A garbage hack.

 

[jasonsw]

that's a fair point. i actually ENJOY an informed & insightful contrarian viewpoint that makes me think, or consider another perspective. but over time, several of these talking head analysts have proven to be neither informed nor insightful. Chris Simms is one of them.

I have a broken grandfather clock in my media room. It is right 2x a day. It's a beautiful piece to look at, but I don't rely on that clock for timeliness.

my point is simply, instead of getting righteously indignant about contrarian hot takes....just ignore them....tune them out. otherwise, you're only feeding the dragon.

When CSP says JW2 is about the 26th best QB in the NFL, I'll pay attention.

Its hard to respect a list that has Daniel Jones at number 21.

Winston's worst season is by far better than Jones' best season as a pro.

 

[jessy]

Daniel Jones (NYG)

Year	Team	CMP%	YDS	TD	INT	Rating
2021	Giants	64.3	2,428	10	7	84.8

Jameis Winston

Year	Team	CMP%	YDS	TD	INT	Rating
2021	Saints	59.0	1,170	14	3	102.8

Not sure what metric Chris is using....

 

[Mamba]

So he should love Jameis, then, no?

He doesn't love his accuracy. But I think Jameis is about to have a big, big year.

 

[los226]

Everyone of those QB’s that are rated above Winston is a joke.

 

[kizzy821]

Don't give him a female name. He's one of YOURS and he's a jackarse.

Own it.

 

[Saint Taysom]

My neighbor is a Falcons fan, and he thinks Mariota is a better QB than Jameis Winston.

His opinion has equal value as Chris Simms.

That value = 0

Who cares

 

[Nola20094EVA]

My point was simply that you shouldn’t dismiss someone’s insights or opinions solely on the basis that he wasn’t an NFL superstar.

I dismiss his crap opinions as he’s as bias as bias can be and obviously let’s his disdain for certain organizations influence his decisions. When this is your job you should throw all dat out the window but that’s typical in the day and age we live in.