Dimke or Graham? (1 Viewer)

[Optimistic Ozzy]

Not discriminating or anything, but I really think that the younger Dimke gives up more upside at the kicker position.
It seems to me that Dimke is very fluid and I'm not sure if he's missed more than one field goal in practice so far. Graham's missed point after and him being injured can't help matters.
I want whomever is best like the rest of us, but for now I'm pulling for Dimke.

 

[Frank The Rat]

Not discriminating or anything, but I really think that the younger Dimke gives up more upside at the kicker position.
It seems to me that Dimke is very fluid and I'm not sure if he's missed more than one field goal in practice so far. Graham's missed point after and him being injured can't help matters.
I want whomever is best like the rest of us, but for now I'm pulling for Dimke.

I went ahead and added a poll to your thread. Makes it easier to see what people are selecting.

 

[RaisingTheBar]

It honestly depends on what you prefer as a fan with your kicker. If you favor a vet with a lot of experience you'd go with Graham. If you favor a younger guy with maybe a stronger leg it's Dimke. I'm torn down the middle I like both. Whoever SP chooses is fine with me.

 

[Madness71]

Dimke

 

[RSF Grace]

I vote experienced vet. After the shambles that Garrett Hartley left me in on a regular basis, I need some stability in my kicker..lol

 

[Optimistic Ozzy]

I went ahead and added a poll to your thread. Makes it easier to see what people are selecting.

Thank you sir !!

 

[scott88]

I want to get the loser of KC's battle between Ryan Succop and Cairo Santos

 

[SaintArchieManning]

I bet there will be an EXCELLENT kicker available after the final cut date.

I vote NEITHER- let's pick up the best-available then.

 

[Optimistic Ozzy]

I want to get the loser of KC's battle between Ryan Succop and Cairo Santos

There's something about the name Suck-up and a kicker I don't want.

 

[St.Stephen]

I want to get the loser of KC's battle between Ryan Succop and Cairo Santos

I'm with this if we don't start Dimke. Dimke is clearly the better choice with his leg strength as well as his intermediate kicks overall. Graham missing the now standard 33 yd extra point the other day is poop. I vote Dimke all day...

Succop would be great because he can hit the 52-55 yd FG's you need at times as well as serve as a backup punter to Morstead. Succop was kicker/punter at South Carolina with the ol' ball coach, and was $$$. He's been great at KC as well.

 

[scott88]

There's something about the name Suck-up and a kicker I don't want.

he's an excellent kicker, the Chiefs might go w/ Santos just because of Succop's contract

 

[duckjr78]

Head says Graham, heart says Dimke.

It's a business, so I channeled my inner Loomis and went with Graham.

 

[Bayouman007]

weather be damned, if graham makes the field goal in seattle... who knows!!!

Dimke for me

 

[Saint Greg]

I'm going for the upside of Dimke and I think Graham will be available if we need to bring him back.

 

[robsmith32]

i've been saying for a while, i hope our kicker is on another squad at the moment..

and people saying dimke has the stronger leg cause he's younger.. I'd like to point out that Graham has made longer kicks in practice than Dimke has. So, i wouldn't necessarily say stronger leg so fast.
I will say though, that Dimke's kick in the St Louis game was a Line drive, right down the middle. Which is a bit more comforting, than watching curve balls, that barely cut inside the goalposts.