players that should of not gone in the PB and players that should have (1 Viewer)

[CJL]

NOT- Jeremey Shockey, Tony Romo, Anquan Boldin, Philip Rivers

Should-Jason Witten, Roy Williams (WR), Lee Evans, Tom Brady


anyone agree?

 

[Loose Cannon]

Well, for starters, you replaced Romo with a wide receiver from the AFC

I tend to agree with Brady over Rivers, even though Brady's numbers aren't as great as usual.

Shockey and Witten is pretty much a tossup for me.

 

[Nonreg]

Roy Williams, Marques Colston, Demco Ryans, Brian Westbrook -- off the top of my head

I'd give the edge to Shockey over Witten also.

 

[Eeyore]

The following players were slighted.

Joseph Addai Running Back Indianapolis Colts
Eric Alexander Linebacker New England Patriots
Bennie Brazell Wide Receiver Cincinnati Bengals
Ryan Clark Safety Pittsburgh Steelers
Travis Daniels Cornerback Miami Dolphins
Domanick Davis Running Back Houston Texans
Alan Faneca Offensive Guard Pittsburgh Steelers
Kevin Faulk Running Back New England Patriots
Randall Gay Cornerback New England Patriots
Jarvis Green Defensive End New England Patriots
Skyler Green Wide Receiver Cincinnati Bengals
Marquise Hill Defensive End New England Patriots
Tory James Cornerback Cincinnati Bengals
Donnie Jones Punter Miami Dolphins
Eddie Kennison Wide Receiver Kansas City Chiefs
Kevin Mawae Center Tennessee Titans
Anthony McFarland Defensive Tackle Indianapolis Colts
Rudy Niswanger Center Kansas City Chiefs
Ronnie Prude Cornerback Baltimore Ravens
Josh Reed Wide Receiver Buffalo Bills
Robert Royal Tight End Buffalo Bills
LaBrandon Toefield Running Back Jacksonville Jaguars
Andrew Whitworth Offensive Guard Cincinnati Bengals
Ben Wilkerson Center Cincinnati Bengals
Kyle Williams Defensive Tackle Buffalo Bills
Claude Wroten Defensive Tackle St. Louis Rams
Kenderick Allen Defensive Tackle Green Bay Packers
Corey Webster Cornerback New York Giants
Marcus Spears Defensive End Dallas Cowboys
Mark Roman Safety San Francisco 49ers
Melvin Oliver Defensive End San Francisco 49ers
Stephen Peterman Offensive Guard Detroit Lions
Todd McClure Center Atlanta Falcons
Bradie James Linebacker Dallas Cowboys
Devery Henderson Wide Receiver New Orleans Saints
Michael Clayton Wide Receiver Tampa Bay Buccaneers

 

[Oates]

The following players were slighted.

Joseph Addai Running Back Indianapolis Colts
Eric Alexander Linebacker New England Patriots
Bennie Brazell Wide Receiver Cincinnati Bengals
Ryan Clark Safety Pittsburgh Steelers
Travis Daniels Cornerback Miami Dolphins
Domanick Davis Running Back Houston Texans
Alan Faneca Offensive Guard Pittsburgh Steelers
Kevin Faulk Running Back New England Patriots
Randall Gay Cornerback New England Patriots
Jarvis Green Defensive End New England Patriots
Skyler Green Wide Receiver Cincinnati Bengals
Marquise Hill Defensive End New England Patriots
Tory James Cornerback Cincinnati Bengals
Donnie Jones Punter Miami Dolphins
Eddie Kennison Wide Receiver Kansas City Chiefs
Kevin Mawae Center Tennessee Titans
Anthony McFarland Defensive Tackle Indianapolis Colts
Rudy Niswanger Center Kansas City Chiefs
Ronnie Prude Cornerback Baltimore Ravens
Josh Reed Wide Receiver Buffalo Bills
Robert Royal Tight End Buffalo Bills
LaBrandon Toefield Running Back Jacksonville Jaguars
Andrew Whitworth Offensive Guard Cincinnati Bengals
Ben Wilkerson Center Cincinnati Bengals
Kyle Williams Defensive Tackle Buffalo Bills
Claude Wroten Defensive Tackle St. Louis Rams
Kenderick Allen Defensive Tackle Green Bay Packers
Corey Webster Cornerback New York Giants
Marcus Spears Defensive End Dallas Cowboys
Mark Roman Safety San Francisco 49ers
Melvin Oliver Defensive End San Francisco 49ers
Stephen Peterman Offensive Guard Detroit Lions
Todd McClure Center Atlanta Falcons
Bradie James Linebacker Dallas Cowboys
Devery Henderson Wide Receiver New Orleans Saints
Michael Clayton Wide Receiver Tampa Bay Buccaneers

I disagree, Alan Faneca had a terrible year.

 

[MoJoMan]

The following players were slighted.

Joseph Addai Running Back Indianapolis Colts
Eric Alexander Linebacker New England Patriots
Bennie Brazell Wide Receiver Cincinnati Bengals
Ryan Clark Safety Pittsburgh Steelers
Travis Daniels Cornerback Miami Dolphins
Domanick Davis Running Back Houston Texans
Alan Faneca Offensive Guard Pittsburgh Steelers
Kevin Faulk Running Back New England Patriots
Randall Gay Cornerback New England Patriots
Jarvis Green Defensive End New England Patriots
Skyler Green Wide Receiver Cincinnati Bengals
Marquise Hill Defensive End New England Patriots
Tory James Cornerback Cincinnati Bengals
Donnie Jones Punter Miami Dolphins
Eddie Kennison Wide Receiver Kansas City Chiefs
Kevin Mawae Center Tennessee Titans
Anthony McFarland Defensive Tackle Indianapolis Colts
Rudy Niswanger Center Kansas City Chiefs
Ronnie Prude Cornerback Baltimore Ravens
Josh Reed Wide Receiver Buffalo Bills
Robert Royal Tight End Buffalo Bills
LaBrandon Toefield Running Back Jacksonville Jaguars
Andrew Whitworth Offensive Guard Cincinnati Bengals
Ben Wilkerson Center Cincinnati Bengals
Kyle Williams Defensive Tackle Buffalo Bills
Claude Wroten Defensive Tackle St. Louis Rams
Kenderick Allen Defensive Tackle Green Bay Packers
Corey Webster Cornerback New York Giants
Marcus Spears Defensive End Dallas Cowboys
Mark Roman Safety San Francisco 49ers
Melvin Oliver Defensive End San Francisco 49ers
Stephen Peterman Offensive Guard Detroit Lions
Todd McClure Center Atlanta Falcons
Bradie James Linebacker Dallas Cowboys
Devery Henderson Wide Receiver New Orleans Saints
Michael Clayton Wide Receiver Tampa Bay Buccaneers

LSU Connection?

 

[jpcdolphan]

The following players were slighted.

Joseph Addai Running Back Indianapolis Colts
Eric Alexander Linebacker New England Patriots
Bennie Brazell Wide Receiver Cincinnati Bengals
Ryan Clark Safety Pittsburgh Steelers
Travis Daniels Cornerback Miami Dolphins
Domanick Davis Running Back Houston Texans
Alan Faneca Offensive Guard Pittsburgh Steelers
Kevin Faulk Running Back New England Patriots
Randall Gay Cornerback New England Patriots
Jarvis Green Defensive End New England Patriots
Skyler Green Wide Receiver Cincinnati Bengals
Marquise Hill Defensive End New England Patriots
Tory James Cornerback Cincinnati Bengals
Donnie Jones Punter Miami Dolphins
Eddie Kennison Wide Receiver Kansas City Chiefs
Kevin Mawae Center Tennessee Titans
Anthony McFarland Defensive Tackle Indianapolis Colts
Rudy Niswanger Center Kansas City Chiefs
Ronnie Prude Cornerback Baltimore Ravens
Josh Reed Wide Receiver Buffalo Bills
Robert Royal Tight End Buffalo Bills
LaBrandon Toefield Running Back Jacksonville Jaguars
Andrew Whitworth Offensive Guard Cincinnati Bengals
Ben Wilkerson Center Cincinnati Bengals
Kyle Williams Defensive Tackle Buffalo Bills
Claude Wroten Defensive Tackle St. Louis Rams
Kenderick Allen Defensive Tackle Green Bay Packers
Corey Webster Cornerback New York Giants
Marcus Spears Defensive End Dallas Cowboys
Mark Roman Safety San Francisco 49ers
Melvin Oliver Defensive End San Francisco 49ers
Stephen Peterman Offensive Guard Detroit Lions
Todd McClure Center Atlanta Falcons
Bradie James Linebacker Dallas Cowboys
Devery Henderson Wide Receiver New Orleans Saints
Michael Clayton Wide Receiver Tampa Bay Buccaneers

Some of those players (well, 2) didn't really have what I would consider a "pro bowl" type of year.

However, there isn't really any doubt that you've composed a list of future 1st ballot Hall of Famers, though!

 

[Puddinhead]

While I tend to agree with Eeyore, this is how I feel:
In the NFC...
Shouldn't Have: A. Boldin, S. Smith, Kris Jenkins, D. Hall, and R. Williams (SS)
In their place: R. Williams (WR), M. Colston, Marques Douglas(DT), Sean Taylor (even though I don't like him), and maybe either Charles Tillman or Antwain Winfield

In the AFC...
Shouldn't Have: Adalius Thomas
In His Place: I don't know???

 

[Waymer]

In the AFC...
Shouldn't Have: Adalius Thomas
In His Place: I don't know???

No way, Thomas has become the heart and soul of that defensive scheme, even more so than Ray Lewis. His versatility and production definitely warrants the selection.

 

[BoNcHiE]

While I tend to agree with Eeyore, this is how I feel:
In the NFC...
Shouldn't Have: A. Boldin, S. Smith, Kris Jenkins, D. Hall, and R. Williams (SS)
In their place: R. Williams (WR), M. Colston, Marques Douglas(DT), Sean Taylor (even though I don't like him), and maybe either Charles Tillman or Antwain Winfield

In the AFC...
Shouldn't Have: Adalius Thomas
In His Place: I don't know???

Smith has better stats then both Colston and Williams. I agree with Roy Williams (SS) and Hall. Both stupid choices to make it to Hawaii.

As for no Adalius Thomas, that dudes a beast.

 

[MOSaintsFan]

The following players were slighted.

Joseph Addai Running Back Indianapolis Colts
Eric Alexander Linebacker New England Patriots
Bennie Brazell Wide Receiver Cincinnati Bengals
Ryan Clark Safety Pittsburgh Steelers
Travis Daniels Cornerback Miami Dolphins
Domanick Davis Running Back Houston Texans
Alan Faneca Offensive Guard Pittsburgh Steelers
Kevin Faulk Running Back New England Patriots
Randall Gay Cornerback New England Patriots
Jarvis Green Defensive End New England Patriots
Skyler Green Wide Receiver Cincinnati Bengals
Marquise Hill Defensive End New England Patriots
Tory James Cornerback Cincinnati Bengals
Donnie Jones Punter Miami Dolphins
Eddie Kennison Wide Receiver Kansas City Chiefs
Kevin Mawae Center Tennessee Titans
Anthony McFarland Defensive Tackle Indianapolis Colts
Rudy Niswanger Center Kansas City Chiefs
Ronnie Prude Cornerback Baltimore Ravens
Josh Reed Wide Receiver Buffalo Bills
Robert Royal Tight End Buffalo Bills
LaBrandon Toefield Running Back Jacksonville Jaguars
Andrew Whitworth Offensive Guard Cincinnati Bengals
Ben Wilkerson Center Cincinnati Bengals
Kyle Williams Defensive Tackle Buffalo Bills
Claude Wroten Defensive Tackle St. Louis Rams
Kenderick Allen Defensive Tackle Green Bay Packers
Corey Webster Cornerback New York Giants
Marcus Spears Defensive End Dallas Cowboys
Mark Roman Safety San Francisco 49ers
Melvin Oliver Defensive End San Francisco 49ers
Stephen Peterman Offensive Guard Detroit Lions
Todd McClure Center Atlanta Falcons
Bradie James Linebacker Dallas Cowboys
Devery Henderson Wide Receiver New Orleans Saints
Michael Clayton Wide Receiver Tampa Bay Buccaneers

Pretty much agreed with your list until I made it down to Devery Henderson...whatever you are smoking pass it on over...must be some good stuff.

Those who drop more than they catch do not make the Pro Bowl

 

[Treybad]

Romo got in because, McNabb is hurt

I really dont see why there is a big fuss over this, it doesnt mean much......

Alot of the times, the starters dont play anyhow...... especially after there playoff runs......

 

[Wahoo]

NOT- Jeremey Shockey, Tony Romo, Anquan Boldin, Philip Rivers

Should-Jason Witten, Roy Williams (WR), Lee Evans, Tom Brady


anyone agree?

...

Shockey and Witten is pretty much a tossup for me.

Witten over Shockey, or even close ?

Shockey: 64 rec, 626 yds, 7 TDs
Witten: 54 rec, 642 yds, 1 TD

Heck, I'd go with Desmond Clark over Witten...

 

[FWtex]

Romo, and Roy Williams should NOT have gotten in. Romo has not played enough to earn a spot. Heck Randle El should go at QB before Romo. Honestly I think McNAbb should have been named and then Romo picked to sub for him.

As for Roy Williams, even his own local media has been dogging him about how bad he is playing this year. Just throw it deep on him.

Kinda odd that the players and Coaches are the ones who really voted these guys in. You would think they would want to hold the PB to a higher standard.

 

[RussTKD]

Smith has better stats then both Colston and Williams. I agree with Roy Williams (SS) and Hall. Both stupid choices to make it to Hawaii.

As for no Adalius Thomas, that dudes a beast.

And a free agent this off season.