NFL Draft Quinn Ewers or Carson Beck? (1 Viewer)

[Tulsa Saint]

Watching UGA vs Texas made me think of this to ask but if you’re the saints and drafting 40ish would you take of of them if they fell or move up a bit to grab one?

Assuming the Saints pick in the 8–10 range that’s way too high for any QB save for Ward or Sanders who’ll be gone.

Both Beck and Ewers have played better as of late so I’m slightly more interested now than a month ago. Any opinions on which guy you’d take? Personally leaning Beck but i can be convinced otherwise.

 

[football]

None of them. I much rather stick with Heaner and Rattler. In fact none of the quarterbacks in this year class appeal to me.

 

[jasonsw]

No way. I've watched both play alot this season.

They are the weak spots on both teams.

What Ewers did last year was a mirage. He was playing against the minor league of college football in the Big12. That conference is a joke plain and simple.

 

[Tulsa Saint]

None of them. I much rather stick with Heaner and Rattler. In fact none of the quarterbacks in this year class appeal to me.

Makes sense and I probably agree just trying to get an opinion on these two specifically.

 

[Tulsa Saint]

No way. I've watched both play alot this season.

They are the weak spots on both teams.

What Ewers did last year was a mirage. He was playing against the minor league of college football in the Big12. That conference is a joke plain and simple.

Questions:


Ewers has a 24/7 TD/Int ratio this season and a similar QB rating to last year. Is his production attributed to the system/talent of Texas and not really him?

Beck has had a ton of drops(most in FBS) does his WRs just stink or something? I realize he had bowers last year or two.

 

[jasonsw]

Questions:


Ewers has a 24/7 TD/Int ratio this season and a similar QB rating to last year. Is his production attributed to the system/talent of Texas and not really him?

Beck has had a ton of drops(most in FBS) does his WRs just stink or something? I realize he had bowers last year or two.

He has feasted against bad teams. Against good teams Ewers has been very average. When a big play dies happen, it is the WR doing all the work. YAC, fighting for catch, etc.

With Beck it is both. N

Neither one can get the ball down the field well or accurately

 

[St. Geezy]

If those are our choices…Derek Carr.

Don’t force the pick.

 

[AARPSaint]

If a potentially great QB is there in the draft, go for it. Otherwise, build the trenches and receivers.

 

[Treybad]

Neither wasting a draft pick on those two

 

[SigFreudianSlip]

Neither.

 

[Linchpinoutdoors]

Pass on all QB options in this draft it's terrible quality batch this year

 

[jahsoul357]

Neither....this QB draft class is boo boo...lol.

Like @AARPSaint said, this is a draft class where you strengthen every other position. This is truly a BPA draft.

 

[killerdescore]

They are terrible
+ we don't really need one ,we need wr/ol/dl/lb/te

 

[Devildog]

Neither

 

[El Caliente]

Death by oogah-boogah