Saints signed Kicker Charlie Smyth (re-signed to 2 year deal) (1 Viewer)

An article from the Athletic this morning featured 3 kickers from Ireland and Gaelic Football getting their shot to the NFL through the IPP program includes Smyth. The article leans heavily towards the guy that started it all, Tadhg Leader, and his journey before starting a company to promote kickers and punters from Ireland.

An interesting tidbit from the article that has been discussed in this thread is kicking in front of large crowds. These guys have experience kicking in front of crowds upwards of 80,000 people and play in a sport as amateur's where they don't get paid. What they lack is experience kicking a football and doing so in game situations. It's an opportunity to do what they love to do and get paid to do it and would be a dream come true for these lads. It would also be a huge win for the NFL to expand their viewership from abroad where in this case these lads are already homeland hero's. Any one of these guys could instantly generate upwards of 5 million new Irish fans to the NFL.

After reading the entire article I came away thinking that in a short span of time we will begin to see some of these kickers and punters from Ireland begin to make their way into the American game of football, both in college and the pros. I've been on record stating that Grupe will retain his starting job and won't be threatened to be replaced by Smyth or any other inexperienced Gaelic Football kicker. However, I came away from this read believing that the learning curve for these Gaelic Football kickers from Ireland will be a quick one and in short time they will get their opportunities to show what they can do playing American football.



Why Gaelic footballers have the NFL’s attention: ‘These lads can kick balls’​

Kalyn Kahler
Apr 11, 2024

TAMPA, Fla. — A tall lad with tousled brown hair and ruddy cheeks flipped through the pages of his light green leather notebook, looking at “wee reminders” to get his head right.

Killer mindset
YOU ABSOLUTELY DESERVE THIS
Teams are watching me. Brilliant!


The kicking workout was the grand finale of the NFL’s International Player Pathway pro day this Wednesday afternoon at the University of South Florida. The event featured the first kickers and punters in the IPP program, which since 2017 has sought to provide players outside of North America with opportunities to play in the league.


Three of the kickers were plucked straight from Gaelic football, Ireland’s most popular sport. Charlie Smyth, 22, of Down, Mark Jackson, 25, of Wicklow, and Rory Beggan, 31, of Monaghan, each left their posts as goalkeepers for their county teams this winter to give NFL kickin’ a fair go.

The lads started kicking NFL footballs this past fall, so Smyth’s wee written reminders were necessary. He stretched outside in the Florida sun before his workout, then took out his phone and watched a cutup of himself making 50-plus yard field goals at this same indoor field.

“I know I can do it here,” he said.

Smyth has been illegally streaming NFL games since he was 16. When he was 18, he sent an email to inquiries@NFL.com pitching himself as an NFL kicker. He never heard back.

This past August, during his off-time from his county team, he finally went to an American football kicking session in Dublin, “just for the craic,” he said. (For the uninitiated, “craic,” pronounced “crack,” means fun in Irish.)

The craic turned serious and led Smyth to the scouting combine, where he caught the eye of several NFL special teams coaches, then to Tampa for this second NFL audience.


go-deeper
GO DEEPER
NFL Draft 2024 ‘The Beast’ Guide: Dane Brugler’s scouting reports and player rankings

The Gaelic kickers were inconsistent past 50 yards in their first appearance in front of NFL teams — “I was kicking myself a bit after the combine,” Beggan said, no pun intended — so this time they wanted to prove they had the distance. When Beggan lined up from 50 yards, he banged it through. Then again from 55 and again from 60. Jackson was perfect through 45 yards and narrowly missed from 50-plus. Smyth drilled his 50-yard attempt, missed from 55, then was good from 60.

After Smyth knocked in his last long attempt, a senior NFL executive who’d been on the field said he expected at least one of the Irish guys to sign with an NFL team, a feat that once seemed outlandish.


“I have to be very honest, I didn’t expect it,” said Ravens assistant special teams coach Randy Brown.

“They were further ahead than everybody expected,” said Saints special teams coordinator Darren Rizzi. “There’s the expression, an ‘NFL leg.’ All of them have an NFL leg.”

These “Irish Gaelic” guys, as special teams coaches call them, seemed to come out of nowhere. So how the feck did they go from kicking 45s and frees to kicking field goals for NFL personnel?



The lad behind the lads is Tadhg Leader. Fair-skinned and ginger-haired and -bearded, Leader is a former professional rugby player from Galway on the west coast of Ireland. He wound up stateside with Major League Rugby in 2018, and when the pandemic hit he started kicking NFL footballs just for the craic.

Soon he started training with John Carney, the former NFL All-Pro who is fifth on the all-time scoring list. Carney encouraged Leader, then 28, to make a career out of kicking, so Leader called the IPP.

The program didn’t carry kickers and punters, so he sent his tape to NFL teams. He was told he needed more game experience, so he played in the Spring League, then European League Football before finally signing with the Canadian Football League’s Hamilton Tiger-Cats in 2022. In his only preseason appearance, he kicked a walk-off 35-yard game-winner.

“Life was great,” Leader said. “I thought I was going to be there for the season.”

But then Hamilton’s general manager called him in and told him he was too raw. Leader was 30 years old, and despite getting more tape, he kept hearing the same feedback.

“Well, like, where else do I get experience?” Leader said.

He tried to kick in the XFL but had issues getting a visa, so he decided to move on. “It’s looking like it’s too late for me,” he said, explaining his mindset. “Let me go home to Ireland to start a pathway that everyone else can walk.”


Last February, Leader started a business to discover Irish kicking talent and help them land college scholarships. He wanted to create a program where cost wouldn’t be a barrier, so he spent his own money at the start, including at least a thousand dollars on footballs. His family thought he’d gone mad.

“It was extremely raw,” Leader said. But in a few months, he’d helped two Irish kickers earn college scholarships and arranged a sponsorship with Delta Airlines.

While Leader was training his first class of soon-to-be collegiate kickers, NFL special teams coordinators convened with the league office to discuss an idea they’d been talking about for years: taking the specialists out of the scouting combine and creating a separate event so they could invite more players and do more kicking.

Brown, the Ravens coach, said that when they presented their vision to NFL EVP of Football operations Troy Vincent, Vincent told them he’d like to see an international component. Last April, James Cook, who runs the IPP and knew of Leader’s quick work with Irish kickers, scheduled a meeting with him at the NFL’s London office.

Leader happened to be in town on business for his day job at J.P. Morgan and snuck away to meet with Cook, who told him they were considering adding kickers and punters to the IPP. Nothing was finalized, but did he think the guys were out there? And if so, could he get them ready in time?

“The biggest barrier that exists is not the capability, but it’s the access,” Leader told Cook. “And if you guys can give access, I can get the kicking talent.”

GettyImages-2139225389-scaled.jpg


Monaghan’s Rory Beggan kicks a free during a match against Cavan on Sunday, April 7. (Ramsey Cardy / Sportsfile via Getty Images)

There are only two sports in the world where athletes kick a ball off the grass and send it high through uprights. And the width of the posts in Gaelic football is only about three feet wider than NFL and college football goal posts.

“Kicking the ball is part of our DNA growing up here in Ireland,” Leader said. “Americans throw baseballs, basketballs, footballs. We don’t do that. We pass those balls with our feet, so now we’ve just been given a new ball to use our feet with …


“It’s the most perfect of synergies, just no one’s ever connected the dots.”

Full Article Below:

 
I was just going to post this article or a link to it. I also think it is interesting that The BLT Ravens ST was impressed with Smythe and the others AND it was mentioned the need for Specialists who could tackle.
 
  • 1Like
Reactions: RJS
Why can't we just get football players that have played football at the position they play growing up like a normal team? No more guys from other sports or guys that grew up in Africa and played one year of high school football. No more guys that played WR or QB in college and trying to turn them into TEs.

The myth is that coaching staffs should tailor the game plan to their players strengths. But the Saints tend to do the opposite and force the players to fit into their game plan.
 
I have a feeling he's just going to sit in that international spot on the practice squad this season and develop. When I've heard people talking about his tryout I've heard 75-81% which makes me think he's not consistent enough yet.
That's consistent enough to win a spot over Grupe as a rookie who will only get better.

He's a draft pick at this point if his leg talent is that of what has been shown.
 
I was just going to post this article or a link to it. I also think it is interesting that The BLT Ravens ST was impressed with Smythe and the others AND it was mentioned the need for Specialists who could tackle.
I wonder if there's any chance with the new rules that the Saints could carry Grupe as the FG kicker and Smyth as a kickoff specialist?
 
That's consistent enough to win a spot over Grupe as a rookie who will only get better.

He's a draft pick at this point if his leg talent is that of what has been shown.

I don’t think it is unless he improves. I think he needs to be head and shoulders over grupe. If it’s remotely close we’ll keep both of them with him sitting in the international spot on our practice squad.
 
I wonder if there's any chance with the new rules that the Saints could carry Grupe as the FG kicker and Smyth as a kickoff specialist?

I hope not. I don’t want to use a game day roster spot on another kicker. If that’s how it goes we need to find a punter who can handle the kickoffs.
 
The myth is that coaching staffs should tailor the game plan to their players strengths. But the Saints tend to do the opposite and force the players to fit into their game plan.
The majority of NFL coaching staffs do this. It’s a common refrain amongst everyone from studio analysts to former players with their own podcasts. A team will draft a transcendent player then try to make him only do things that are within the coaching expertise of his position coach/coordinator, “coaching out” the rest of what makes him special.
 
I wonder if there's any chance with the new rules that the Saints could carry Grupe as the FG kicker and Smyth as a kickoff specialist?

It wouldn't be worth it. Distance is not what teams will be looking for this season on kickoffs. Remember, under the new rules, if a kickoff goes into or out of the endzone this year the touchback comes all the way out to the 30. The new rules are designed to have balls land between the endzone and 20 to encourage returns, but theoretically safer ones.
 
I wonder if there's any chance with the new rules that the Saints could carry Grupe as the FG kicker and Smyth as a kickoff specialist?
I hope not. I don’t want to use a game day roster spot on another kicker. If that’s how it goes we need to find a punter who can handle the kickoffs.
It wouldn't be worth it. Distance is not what teams will be looking for this season on kickoffs. Remember, under the new rules, if a kickoff goes into or out of the endzone this year the touchback comes all the way out to the 30. The new rules are designed to have balls land between the endzone and 20 to encourage returns, but theoretically safer ones.

He won't count against the Saints 53-man roster, but he would count against the gameday roster if suited up.

As Waymer stated above, kickoff distance is no longer a plus with the new rules in place. Also, the new kickoff rule doesn't allow the kicker to go beyond mid field.

However, as a last line of defense on the kickoff team Smyth (6'4", 210 pounds) would present a much bigger presence than Grupe (5'7", 157 pounds) and coming from Gaelic Football is used to roughing it up some. We don't know yet what other measurements Smyth has in regard to speed and strength.

Wouldn't it be a pleasant surprise to find out in training camp that Smyth is a natural special teams force with speed, strength, agility, and a desire to be a special teams headhunter who can lay the wood on the opponent and makes the team as a core special teamer. Special teamers will now have more value than before. It will be interesting to see what all this lad has to offer or what he is limited to.
 
We have re-signed Charlie on a 2 year deal, per his Instagram. I guess that makes him the first signing of the rebuild, on day 1!

I would expect that is on Practice Squad terms matching what he is on this year but I would really hope he will give some serious competition to Grupe in Camp now that he has a year under his belt. I also hope that we might think about using the exemption we get for an international player to be added as an additional slot to the game day roster I think 4 games of the year and let him try a 60something yarder should needs dictate.

Either way, well done Charlie, keep working and Up County Down!
 
Last edited:
We have re-signed Charlie on a 2 year deal, per his Instagram. I guess that makes him the first signing of the rebuild, on day 1!

I would expect that is on Practice Squad terms matching what he is on this year but I would really hope he will give some serious competition to Grupe in Camp now that he has a year under his belt. I also hope that we might think about using the exemption we get for an international player to be added as an additional slot to the game day roster I think 4 games of the year and let him try a 60something harder should needs dictate.

Either way, well done Charlie, keep working and Up County Down!
It’s a standard min. FA deal to sign him back to the roster. Charlie’s salary will be standard 1st-2nd year NFL rostered vet salary in 700K-1M+ range until/unless he goes to the practice squad again. But practice squad isn’t determined until the end of August.
 
We have re-signed Charlie on a 2 year deal, per his Instagram. I guess that makes him the first signing of the rebuild, on day 1!

I would expect that is on Practice Squad terms matching what he is on this year but I would really hope he will give some serious competition to Grupe in Camp now that he has a year under his belt. I also hope that we might think about using the exemption we get for an international player to be added as an additional slot to the game day roster I think 4 games of the year and let him try a 60something harder should needs dictate.

Either way, well done Charlie, keep working and Up County Down!
I would expect if Grupe keeps doing what he's doing he will be fine. Dude has been solid. If we got rid of Grupe he would be picked up in 5 minutes.
 
It’s a standard min. FA deal to sign him back to the roster. Charlie’s salary will be standard 1st-2nd year NFL rostered vet salary in 700K-1M+ range until/unless he goes to the practice squad again. But practice squad isn’t determined until the end of August.
This is true, but I was under the understanding (maybe wrong) that Charlie is on some kind of specific International Player Pathway contract tied to the practice squad, that then comes with those exemptions rather than a classic rookie minimum deal.

Either way, as I think I mentioned earlier in this thread when he signed, he was teaching elementary school kids probably on the equivalent of about $35/40k per year and playing an amateur sport before starting the journey to the NFL, so it really is life changing for him even to be on those terms and a great story.
 

Create an account or login to comment

You must be a member in order to leave a comment

Create account

Create an account on our community. It's easy!

Log in

Already have an account? Log in here.

Users who are viewing this thread

    Back
    Top Bottom