The Electric Vehicle (EV) discussion thread (Merged) (4 Viewers)

superchuck500

tiny changes
VIP Subscribing Member
VIP Contributor
Diamond VIP Contributor
Joined
Aug 9, 2004
Messages
60,168
Reaction score
93,276
Location
Charleston, SC
Offline
Jaguar's I-Pace has been delivering for a few months now - the reviews are strong.

The body style is hard to define - not quite the 4-door coupe lines that the Model S gives you. Almost more like a crossover . . . but also something somewhat unique, almost futuristic. The power and handling are said to be undeniable and apparently the car is magnificent to drive. Of course, with any new model it appears there are issues that Jaguar will have to resolve, including a clunky interface and some charging issues.

But in going over a few reviews, the one thing that is consistent is how great it is to drive the car. The acceleration, the cornering (aided by all sorts of technology), the audible experience, etc. - everyone loves to drive it. Even Consumer Reports described the driving experience as "beautiful."

If Jaguar can clean up the issues with the interface, and bring it to the kind of reliability they have on the rest of their line, it will no-doubt put a hurt on Tesla. And the luxury EV market is still just getting going.




https://www.consumerreports.org/hybrids-evs/2019-jaguar-i-pace-first-drive-review/


114515
 
Last edited:
Joined
Aug 10, 2018
Messages
2,115
Reaction score
4,618
Location
The Vieux
Online
I know Jags had a reputation for being very unreliable. Has that changed in recent years?
 
OP
superchuck500

superchuck500

tiny changes
VIP Subscribing Member
VIP Contributor
Diamond VIP Contributor
Joined
Aug 9, 2004
Messages
60,168
Reaction score
93,276
Location
Charleston, SC
Offline
I know Jags had a reputation for being very unreliable. Has that changed in recent years?

Yes. They have done well in JD Power for a good decade or longer - it seems that getting pulled into larger automaker umbrellas helped their quality. They were at or near the top in some dependability and satisfaction rankings but have slipped a bit. Still decent.
 

Kegger

Up North
Joined
Apr 13, 2004
Messages
3,432
Reaction score
1,756
Online
I can't imagine this doing particularly well, but the more options in the EV market the better.
 
OP
superchuck500

superchuck500

tiny changes
VIP Subscribing Member
VIP Contributor
Diamond VIP Contributor
Joined
Aug 9, 2004
Messages
60,168
Reaction score
93,276
Location
Charleston, SC
Offline
I can't imagine this doing particularly well, but the more options in the EV market the better.

Jaguar reported sales of 11,000 I Pace cars in Q1 and it’s just ramping up.

In comparison, Tesla reported Q1 sales of 12,100 of models S and X combined - the models most comparable to the I Pace.




Here is the list of awards the I-Pace has racked up including European Car of the Year and COTY at the recent NY Auto Show.

  • Arab Wheels "2018 EV of the Year" [26]
  • What Car? 2018 Reader Award - "Most Anticipated Car of 2018" [27]
  • Selected for AutoCar Awards "2018 Game Changer" [28]
  • 2018 Auto Express "Car of the Year" and "Premium EV of the Year" [29]
  • "2018 Car of the Year" by Sunday Times [30]
  • 2019 "German Car of the Year"[31]
  • T3 Technology Awards: "Best Car of 2018"[32]
  • Robb Report "October 2018 Car of the Month"[33]
  • Motor Authority "Best Car to Buy 2019" Finalist [34]
  • "Swiss Car of the Year 2019" [35]
  • Overall Winner - Irish Times "Top 100 Cars of 2019" [36]
  • Overall "Car of the Year" and "Best Alternative Fuel Car" at the 2018 Scottish Car of the Year awards[37]
  • 2019 "Car of the Year" by ExtremeTech [38]
  • "Best Premium Electric Car" - Sunday Express [39]
  • Winner - "European Car of the Year 2019" award[40]
  • Finalist in Motor Trend "SUV of the Year"[41]
  • China's "2019 Green Car of the Year"[42]
  • "2019 Scottish Car of the Year"[43]
  • Green Car Reports "Best Car to Buy 2019" Finalist [44]
  • "Best Car of the Year 2018" by Pocket Lint[45]
  • "Best Luxury Compact SUV 2019" by U.S. News & World Report [46]
  • ALG's "2019 Residual Value Award" for Electric Category[47]
  • Popular Science "Best of 2018 Innovations" - Grand Award Winner[48]
  • Driving Electric's 2019 "Best Large Electric Car" [49]
  • "Luxury Green Car of the Year" - LA's 14th Annual Green Car Awards [50]
  • "18 Best Rides of 2018" - Chicago Tribune [51]
  • Professional Driver magazine "2018 Car of the Year"[52]
  • "Top 10 Car of the Year" - The National [53]
  • Forbes "Best Car Designs of 2018"[54]
  • Stuff Magazine "Car of the Year 2018"[55]
  • Top Gear magazine "EV of the Year 2018"[56]
  • "Norwegian Car of the Year 2019"[57]
  • CleanTechnica "2019 Car of the Year" Finalist[58]
  • GQ 2019 Car Awards: "Best Electric Car You'd Actually Drive"[59]
  • WhichCar "Style Awards 2019" - Finalist [60]
  • "2019 North American Utility Vehicle of the Year" Runner Up [61]
  • MotorWeek "Best of the Year 2019"[62]
  • "Best Executive UK Car of the Year 2019"[63]
  • CarBuyer "Safest Cars to Buy 2019"[64]
  • "Canada Utility Vehicle of the Year 2019"[65]
  • Overall Winner - 2019 "World Car of the Year", "World Green Car of the Year", "World Car Design of the Year" [66][67]
  • AutoWeek Magazine "2019 Quietest Cars on Sale" [68]
  • "2019 UK Car of the Year - Overall Winner"[69]
  • "Canada Green Utility Vehicle of the Year 2019"[70]
  • Best EV - Business Motoring Awards 2019[71]
  • AutoBest's "ECOBEST" Award 2018 [72]
  • AutoTrader - Best New Cars for 2019[73]
 

The Moose

ALL-MADDEN TEAM
Joined
Aug 13, 2001
Messages
2,938
Reaction score
1,902
Offline
An electric car made in the UK?
No thanks.

Come on man Lucas has not been involved in limey cars for a long time.

I am sure they have done away with the positive ground nonsense years ago.


On to the Tesla thing. They are gonna get clobbered by bigger car companies once they start to come into the marketplace.

They are on borrowed time. The auto industry knows a hell of a lot more about the auto industry than Tesla and none are run by an egomaniac that has to be in the press.

With that all said I really don't think the electric cars are the only answer.

They are filthy things. Cobalt for the batteries is mined by children in the Congo. MINED by KIDS! If you want to save the world start with them. If your electric car is being charged by a coal burning plant are you really saving the world?

Everyone let's not forget the auto industry was making great strides in mpg and being cleaner.

In fact Mazda has a great new engine that is super efficient and clean.

It is the holy Grail of gas engines. It fires from from squeeze like a diesel. It is about a clean burn.

They in fact are working on getting the thermal efficiency to that of a electric car charged on a natural gas plant

 
OP
superchuck500

superchuck500

tiny changes
VIP Subscribing Member
VIP Contributor
Diamond VIP Contributor
Joined
Aug 9, 2004
Messages
60,168
Reaction score
93,276
Location
Charleston, SC
Offline
With that all said I really don't think the electric cars are the only answer.

They are filthy things. Cobalt for the batteries is mined by children in the Congo. MINED by KIDS! If you want to save the world start with them. If your electric car is being charged by a coal burning plant are you really saving the world?

This is definitely part of the EV discussion. Cobalt sourcing is troubling. Battery disposal is another nasty business.

I think the carbon emissions comparisons have been done when it comes to total energy involved and the EVs still come out a little better on a per mile basis than gas power, even on coal-burning plants. And obviously it gets significantly better when you start talking about nuclear and renewable power.

It’s called “well to wheel” emissions - recognizing that you have to account for EV power creation. The government studies that have looked to compare them have concluded that even when you include the energy consumption involved in creating the battery, the total emissions that can be accounted to the EV is still meaningfully lower than with gasoline cars, on average, and as the share of total US power produced with gas and green plants grows every year - a trend that further reduces total emissions for the EV. Of course mpg gains on the gas side also have a positive trend.

I think the range remains a problem for many people. Daily driving is great but many people have access to only one car but do, from time to time, need to go more than 250 miles in a day. Even if it’s just a handful of times a year, it seems that the sort of interstate off-ramp refueling stations aren’t common at all - and recharge times can still be lengthy.








 

BooBirdSaint

Super Forum Fanatic
Platinum VIP Contributor
Joined
Jan 17, 2007
Messages
11,539
Reaction score
10,636
Location
Houston, Texas
Offline
Western auto makers are marketing to the largest market on the planet, China. 25million cars are produced in China annually. How many are hybrids or electric? Less than 1% US and Euopean electric sales are but a drop in the ocean. Until you flip that economy then its really the law of diminishing returns. China and India must get on board or any carbon gains made in the West get washed out two or three times over.
We are killing ourselves and this planet by feeding that economy.
 

The Moose

ALL-MADDEN TEAM
Joined
Aug 13, 2001
Messages
2,938
Reaction score
1,902
Offline


What I absolutely love about that graph is they are talking about mpg in a 25k dollar car compared to what your 75k+ car would cost to drive from NY and it only has range to get to new Jersey.

Even if you did stop and charge it it would be faster to take a friggin train.
 

The Moose

ALL-MADDEN TEAM
Joined
Aug 13, 2001
Messages
2,938
Reaction score
1,902
Offline
This is definitely part of the EV discussion. Cobalt sourcing is troubling. Battery disposal is another nasty business.

I think the carbon emissions comparisons have been done when it comes to total energy involved and the EVs still come out a little better on a per mile basis than gas power, even on coal-burning plants. And obviously it gets significantly better when you start talking about nuclear and renewable power.

It’s called “well to wheel” emissions - recognizing that you have to account for EV power creation. The government studies that have looked to compare them have concluded that even when you include the energy consumption involved in creating the battery, the total emissions that can be accounted to the EV is still meaningfully lower than with gasoline cars, on average, and as the share of total US power produced with gas and green plants grows every year - a trend that further reduces total emissions for the EV. Of course mpg gains on the gas side also have a positive trend.

I think the range remains a problem for many people. Daily driving is great but many people have access to only one car but do, from time to time, need to go more than 250 miles in a day. Even if it’s just a handful of times a year, it seems that the sort of interstate off-ramp refueling stations aren’t common at all - and recharge times can still be lengthy.










The key here is to get engines more thermaly efficient.

The link in the article I posted about Mazda skyactiv engines talks about where they have to get to be as efficient as an ev with the current grid and they are not really that far away.

The tech of that Mazda engine is something else. Next level stuff.

It runs crazy high compression like a diesel. 16 to 1 actually. The cylinder is then filled with a air fuel mix that is too lean to combust on it's own at that compression. Then at the very top of the stroke it injects in the correct amount of fuel for the combustion. Therefore it gets a far more power and a much cleaner burn than a regular combustion engine without the preignition or knocking you would get.

The combustion engine is not dead it is just the ev hype.
 
  • 1Like
Reactions: You

Create an account or login to comment

You must be a member in order to leave a comment

Create account

Create an account on our community. It's easy!

Log in

Already have an account? Log in here.

Users who are viewing this thread

 

New Orleans Saints Twitter Feed

 

Headlines

Top Bottom