How long should a successful rebuild take?

Yeah it is unfortunate. Cut losses and move on. Unfortunately, the team-building strategy employed under Payton has the team in a harder hole to climb out of.
That’s true. But the hole he had to work with in Denver wasn’t much different than what he had the last year that he was in New Orleans. It just seems that he had a good reason to want to start a rebuild somewhere else.
 
I don't believe all rebuilds are created equally. Sometimes teams find themselves needing an overhaul and have a plethora of resources to do so. Other teams may have spent those resources trying to re-tool and/or extend past success. It all comes down to the starting line a team is beginning at, as well as what kind of young core it has built in to build around. Teams who have pushed their starting line way back will have a longer way to go. Unless a team gets really luckky, correcting financial matters doesn't happen quickly.
 
Last edited:
you think I forgot about Katrina? Come on man. No team or fan base ever went through something that bad. That said, the Saints were on a one year losing season streak going into 06. Broncos are riding a streak of 7 straight.
You posted that the Saints 05 season was the worst in NFL history, UNTIL this years Broncos. A 7 season losing streak doesn't hold a candle to the 1st 40 years in NOLA, much less the effects of the 05 season & the previous 20 years!

The Saints' had 7 winning seasons, 14 losing/even from 1985-2005. 5 playoff appearances & 1 win, with 5 coaches.
Broncos had 14 winning seasons, & 7 losing/even from 1985-2005; 12 playoff appearance & won 2 SuperBowls, with 3 coaches.
I'll gladly trade those records.

Hell the Jets have only 1 winning season out of the last 14 & aren't sniffing another, much less the playoffs.
 
That’s true. But the hole he had to work with in Denver wasn’t much different than what he had the last year that he was in New Orleans. It just seems that he had a good reason to want to start a rebuild somewhere else.
The money hole from the last year in New Orleans was the result of years pursuing his wishes.

Those didn’t manifest, either. The team was closer from 2017-2020, yes, in that they made the playoffs all four seasons.

It’s not like Brees left and the Saints became a 3-win team, so I think it made sense to keep trying to win. Dennis Lauscha grew up a Saints fan in New Orleans and probably doesn’t want to go back to the franchise’s old losing ways - and I think that order is passed down to the entire front office.

Maybe the Madden Football game GMs think one-year turnarounds are easily replicable, from competing against 31 manipulable AIs… in reality there are 31 other franchises that also want nothing more than to win, and they’re trying everything they can to compete, too.
 
Needn a quarterback and getting rid of a lot of old/loved vets saints have to get younger.
 
You posted that the Saints 05 season was the worst in NFL history, UNTIL this years Broncos. A 7 season losing streak doesn't hold a candle to the 1st 40 years in NOLA, much less the effects of the 05 season & the previous 20 years!

The Saints' had 7 winning seasons, 14 losing/even from 1985-2005. 5 playoff appearances & 1 win, with 5 coaches.
Broncos had 14 winning seasons, & 7 losing/even from 1985-2005; 12 playoff appearance & won 2 SuperBowls, with 3 coaches.
I'll gladly trade those records.

Hell the Jets have only 1 winning season out of the last 14 & aren't sniffing another, much less the playoffs.
You grossly misquoted me but it’s not worth arguing. I’ve been a Saints fan since Archie so I know the history.
 
Which part is a misquote?

"Biggest outlier until….this years Broncos."
"Biggest outlier until….this years Broncos" was a reply to somebody else's post that stated that the turnaround from 2005 was an outlier and nobody should expect results so quickly. I never said the 2005 Saints season was the worst in NFL history. Read the whole thread before you just start flaming people.
 
There's been a lot of talk around here about wanting the Saints to do a complete rebuild of the team so that the fans can once again have a team that we can all be proud of. But you're probably asking, "How long to do what?" True, what is considered a successful rebuild by one fan can be quite different from another. If you're wanting to reshuffle the cards in hopes of a royal flush you can't reasonably expect to get that hand as quickly as you might get a full house.

For conversation purposes we'll just add into the equation the goal of being better than the 4th Seed in the NFL playoffs. Let's face it, in today's NFL it's not unusual for the 4th Seed in the playoffs to still be a pretty mediocre ball club if they got there simply because they happened to be in a division where every team in it is a dumpster fire. We've seen in some case where the 5th, 6th, & 7th seeded wildcard teams are much better than the winner of the worst division in the conference.

So the question is, 'How long should it take a team who is rebuilding at every key position to become one of the top three seeded teams in your conference playoffs on a regular basis?' And as a bonus discussion, 'Who has the primary role of fielding a team that is capable of achieving that goal on a consistent basis?'

Is it reasonable to assume that such a goal could be reached fairly quickly? :unsure:
There's alot of complexity to that question. I see alot of people talk about Sean Payton, but one reason I believe Sean Payton was so successful as quickly as he was because he was ahead of his time and above the curve. His Utilization of Reggie Bush, Basically he was Deebo Samual, matching reggie on slow line backers, making Safeties cover Colston. Numerous examples. But Over time the Division Caught up with Payton then finally the league as well and here lies I believe is the Saints issues and rebuilding process. It feels we are trying to build off of Payton's foundation, DA and PC so it feels we are behind now. Examples successful teams are moving away pocket passers, we still have one. Teams utilizing motion we just Hire Kubiak but we already 4-5 years behind and Kubiak needs a year or 2 to draft and get FA and players to stay healthy. On Def we are very old and slow and cant be relied on to carry an offense. So if we draft a QB he will have a bad year or 2 to start and our def cant keep the game close we be the Bears. If we sign older non mobile QB we got what we got now. I think alot needs to go right for a 3yr turn around IMO
 
As someone that has followed this team for 50 years, I am not as optimistic as many of you that think a rebuild will take 2/3 years. We need a coach, maybe GM, need to cut well over $50m from the salary cap, our limited talent is old and will decline significantly over the next 2 years and our last 4/5 drafts have not gone well. This is not a recipe for success.

I see them reaching for a QB with a high 1st round pick and the guy turning out to be a bust. New York Jets come to mind. Hopefully I am wrong but the stars are not lined up for us in the short to medium tern.
 
As someone that has followed this team for 50 years, I am not as optimistic as many of you that think a rebuild will take 2/3 years. We need a coach, maybe GM, need to cut well over $50m from the salary cap, our limited talent is old and will decline significantly over the next 2 years and our last 4/5 drafts have not gone well. This is not a recipe for success.

I see them reaching for a QB with a high 1st round pick and the guy turning out to be a bust. New York Jets come to mind. Hopefully I am wrong but the stars are not lined up for us in the short to medium tern.
I’m leaning on the side of needing a five year plan. But it’s hard to mention that around here without being savagely ostracized.
 
I’m leaning on the side of needing a five year plan. But it’s hard to mention that around here without being savagely ostracized.
I think it’s because most people think “five years of losing” when you say that.
You can still be competitive during that timeframe.
 

Create an account or login to comment

You must be a member in order to leave a comment

Create account

Create an account on our community. It's easy!

Log in

Already have an account? Log in here.

Back
Top Bottom