Media Derek Carr is still top ten in QBR this season per ESPN (1 Viewer)

[kcirdor]

Honestly when i looked at qbs afterwards, i noticed i missed some.. so again it was just an exercise. But if it opens up a more communal exercise, cool.

 

[SWJJ]

Honestly when i looked at qbs afterwards, i noticed i missed some.. so again it was just an exercise. But if it opens up a more communal exercise, cool.

I agree with your overall point that outside the elite or top tier group the rest are largely pretty interchangeable.

 

[St. Geezy]

People say he is top 15... just seems low.
1 mahomes
2 lamar
3 burrow
4 allen
5 stafford
6 herbert
7 cousins
8 hurts
9 goff
10 carr
11 dak
12 stroud
13 mayfield
14 Rodgers
15 geno

10 through 15 might be interchangeable so maybe not low. Just wanted to go through the exercise... these are not an actual ranking, i didnt really dig much deeper than the top of my head.

Yeah I think he’s a top 10 to 12 QB, but I think he’s perceived as lower only because people are using an old bar or standard of QB that doesn’t currently exist. He doesn’t LOOK like what a top 10 QB used to look like, if that makes sense.

 

[DSnfla]

Carr is a top 15 QB w/ moments of Top 5 play when everything around him is ideal, and moments of bottom 25 play when things aren't,

The problem w/ that is, it's the NFL...more often than not, everything isn't going to be Ideal for a full season.

Of the 32 staring QBs I think you can say that about 25 -26 of them