List of Saints and their practice status today. (Thursday) (2 Viewers)

[MJ in Calif]

My guess is, given how CSP is with injuries, we won't know who is starting at QB until Saturday when it is too late for the Falcons to game plan.

 

[Nolan]

Is this the first time in the history of injury report that a player is listed full and not everybody is happy? Very interesting

Are you making stuff up? Everyone looks to be pretty happy about the report.

 

[SystemShock]

I think it is Siemian who should start, even if Taysom is cleared. Already Taysom doesn't practice much QB'ing to begin with, and you add the 3 weeks he was not practicing...

 

[efil4stnias]

I just wanna see Turner 100%

and a D line of Cam, Onyemata, Dav and Turner ( both on same side ).

This should be really fun to see who bull rushes the fastest to the QB

 

[gummbo70114]

My guess is, given ho CSP is with injuries, we won't know who is starting at QB until Saturday when it is too late for the Falcons to game plan.

The only game plan Atlanta is going to be doing is whether or not they lose with dignity or they birch and moan about it. #AtlantaIsGoingToAtlanta

 

[SuperSaint]

Is Taysom taking the snaps as the starter or Semien? Haven't seen that comment yet.

That's what matters, in journalism circles, that's called 'Burying the lead...'

 

[Saint Taysom]

I think it is Siemian who should start, even if Taysom is cleared. Already Taysom doesn't practice much QB'ing to begin with, and you add the 3 weeks he was not practicing...

But the entire offseason and preseason where Taysom was working at QB and splitting starter reps doesn’t count for anything?

I almost wish Siemian would get the start so everyone with the delusion that he’s the answer can see the reality… but I don’t want to see the Saints lose to the Failclowns. I’ve re-watched that Tampa game twice now since Halloween, and the fact is… the Saints got really lucky while Siemian was QB-ing. Yes, he made a few nice throws… but he was not good.

 

[Sailorsaint]

Is Taysom taking the snaps as the starter or Semien? Haven't seen that comment yet.

I hope SP announces TH as the starter then trots TS out on the field, saying there was a setback or last second injury, just to see the look on the Falcons faces after they gameplanned for the wrong QB. Or vice versa for that matter. Either one would throw a wrench in their plans and a knot in their stomach.

 

[Centmssaint1]

Is Taysom taking the snaps as the starter or Semien? Haven't seen that comment yet.

Payton keeping that close to the vest. I would too. Don’t let Atlanta know until the kickoff.

 

[Saint Kamara]

Oh Boy. Taysom has a full practice. Buckle up. This thread is going to be bumpy ride.

yeah because everyone is going to come to their senses and agree we need an extra weapon on offense (i.e., Taysom Hill) and Siemian is the guy this week

 

[Centmssaint1]

But the entire offseason and preseason where Taysom was working at QB and splitting starter reps doesn’t count for anything?

I almost wish Siemian would get the start so everyone with the delusion that he’s the answer can see the reality… but I don’t want to see the Saints lose to the Failclowns. I’ve re-watched that Tampa game twice now since Halloween, and the fact is… the Saints got really lucky while Siemian was QB-ing. Yes, he made a few nice throws… but he was not good.

Take off that tinfoil hat. That guy was pretty good coming in cold like that.

 

[nakadish]

Are you making stuff up? Everyone looks to be pretty happy about the report.

Common now, there's at least "one" person not happy about it, assuming Hill is starting. Trevor Siemian.

 

[504gks]

Is Taysom taking the snaps as the starter or Semien? Haven't seen that comment yet.

Sean has that grin back

 

[football]

Are you making stuff up? Everyone looks to be pretty happy about the report.

Not from what reading through all the nonsense debate on who should or shouldn't be starting.

 

[livefromDC]

But the entire offseason and preseason where Taysom was working at QB and splitting starter reps doesn’t count for anything?

I almost wish Siemian would get the start so everyone with the delusion that he’s the answer can see the reality… but I don’t want to see the Saints lose to the Failclowns. I’ve re-watched that Tampa game twice now since Halloween, and the fact is… the Saints got really lucky while Siemian was QB-ing. Yes, he made a few nice throws… but he was not good.

This is "almost" outright disgusting. As luck will have it all of our QBs entered the season with question marks. Winston won. I was all aboard with Winston. He performed admirably with very little help at WR. He was injured. If it's Hill now, he's dealing with a concussion that knocked him off the field for 3 weeks AND little help at WR, only slightly better than what Winston had, but also having not practiced at QB for weeks. And you know what? I'd hope he kills it. If it's Siemian, he's been an after thought for months, only getting reps with 3rd and 4th strings. And if he's the guy, I hope has an amazing season too.

Stop with all this damn player cheerleading. Especially if it's to the point where you're "almsot" hoping that reality is our players having a bad game in their first start for the team. What TF is that? For the love of all things Holy and Saints, why can't y'all just support whoever walks out there? We don't have to have these circle **** fights BEFORE they even play.