Now we have to roll with Hill. (4 Viewers)

[Rdanderson91]

He can't take hits coming off a concussion. That's my concern.

Mine too. The fact he’s been out several weeks is already concerning.

 

[SaintsFan11]

He can't take hits coming off a concussion. That's my concern.

If he can’t take hits then he certainly isn’t returning to his Swiss Army Knife role.

 

[Jb25saints]

I don’t understand why some “fans” hate Taysom coming i. To play quarterback, but I’m sure the reasons extend off the field.

It’s his Vision and deep ball accuracy that people hate. I think he’s an exciting player.

 

[StudioSaint]

He can't take hits coming off a concussion. That's my concern.

Then he's done on special teams and the joker role on offense. His concussion came while running a route, not playing QB.

 

[blackadder]

the thing with taysom is he holds on to the ball and have a slow release

This.

As a a QB reading the field Hill is just less decisive. Simien has work and was off on a few throws, but also made some great ones. Good delivery and he looks decisive, understands what he is seeing and finds the receiver. Only knock today was placement on some throws.

Siemian looks crisper as a QB than Hill.

 

[El Caliente]

Honestly, he should look out for his best interest and reevaluate his style of play.

 

[blackadder]

Then he's done on special teams and the joker role on offense. His concussion came while running a route, not playing QB.

And if his concussion issues are a danger now, yes, that questions if he can take the hits with the joker role and really calls his career into question if his fall back is just to be a pocket QB. I guess we'll find out.

 

[StudioSaint]

And if his concussion issues are a danger now, yes, that questions if he can take the hits with the joker role and really calls his career into question if his fall back is just to be a pocket QB. I guess we'll find out.

That's the thing, I see people saying he shouldn't be the starting QB because of his concussion concern, so he should just stay in the joker role. That doesn't make sense.

If he isn't safe to play QB because of concussion concerns, then he really can't play football at all.

The way I see it, he's either the Saints starting QB for the rest of the season or he's not not playing at all.

 

[perret318]

It’s his Vision and deep ball accuracy that people hate. I think he’s an exciting player.

If by that you mean his LACK of vision and LACK of deep ball accuracy, then yes.
And indecisiveness, and ball insecurity.

But you know, other than that...

 

[UFCSaint]

Disagree. Let Simien take over...with Hill playing the same joker role. I also wouldn't mind seeing what we have with Book.

 

[BayouSAINTJoe]

If by that you mean his LACK of vision and LACK of deep ball accuracy, then yes.
And indecisiveness, and ball insecurity.

But you know, other than that...

He's exciting when doing all of the things that QBs don't do...but his actually playing QB leaves a lot to be desired.

 

[Saint Dupree]

For Hill to be successful, Sean needs to revamp the offense to take advantage of his particular skill set.

Winston proved to me to have better pocket awareness and escapability than Hill has shown. A hill-led offense must rely on far more designed QB runs, to be successful. We will see now just how successful, or not that type of offense can be.

No, it's the opposite. There needs to be LESS designed runs....everyone is gameplanning that. He still needs his designed runs but not so many and more running when plays break down or nothing there

 

[perret318]

He's exciting when doing all of the things that QBs don't do...but his actually playing QB leaves a lot to be desired.

That may be the most accurate depiction of Taysom Hill that I've ever read.

 

[big screen D]

No, it's the opposite. There needs to be LESS designed runs....everyone is gameplanning that. He still needs his designed runs but not so many and more running when plays break down or nothing there

Coach needs to gameplan completely differently if Hill is going to start the rest of the year. QB draw, bootlegs, RPO, and QB power to name a few will have to become our bread and butter IMO.

 

[kennystillsfan]

I’m dreading seeing a Taysom led offense