Not saying it isn't, he is not living up to the money or expectations. I was just pointing out that the criticism does happen and that outside of the money aspect it's pretty much a mirror image of the way it happens when it's Jameis who struggles.Because it's true
You’d have a better point if there wasn’t an almost decade of evidence that the end result is the same result Winston has produced his entire career. He tosses up risky 50/50 balls with alarming frequency. Sometimes you’ll get a string of heads and people start to believe Winston has figured it out, then the tails inevitably start hitting.
No it isnt...there's no mirror like image to what JW goes through vs what Carr does....not even remotely close....this threads existence in its own is evidence to the contrary. and hell, within this very thread folks are complaining about how the touchdowns looked while completely ignoring that Carr didn't even throw a TD or put us in position to score a TD through 2 and a half quarters of football.
. 
That 3rd and 3 was a punt. The play was toast from snap with the free blitzer.
We'll have to agree to disagree I guess (I actually don't think Carr or Winston are sheet, it's just that neither one is consistent or "good.") I honestly don't see much of a difference in it in general.. like I've said a couple of times, infoman and maybe a few others get off on Winston struggling but I see the same thing in regards to Carr and in my opinion there hasn't been enough of a difference in terms of performance between the two for any of it to really matter to anyone beyond the additional money we spent on Carr.No it isnt...there's no mirror like image to what JW goes through vs what Carr does....not even remotely close....this threads existence in its own is evidence to the contrary. and hell, within this very thread folks are complaining about how the touchdowns looked while completely ignoring that Carr didn't even throw a TD or put us in position to score a TD through 2 and a half quarters of football.
Look, the past 2 years all we heard was "so and so aint it"..."he's not a starter", "he needs to take a prove it deal", "we'll be better once we get "Franchize QB"" and so on. Some of us tried to tell yall, the problem isn't the QB...we got told to "ST(F)U Jameis worshippers he's the problem". So the Saints went out, spent $150M on a "Franchize QB" and whatya know....we still have the same problems. But now we even had the opportunity to see within a single game the teams ineffectiveness with the $150M QB and some semblance of life w/ the guy yall told us wasn't
I mean GD, look no further than Olave's demeanor as to who he thinks the problem is. Its all good though, Carrs the guy, if he's healthy he'll play, some of us just kinda wish that same standard applied last year.
We got three drives after the first two TDs with 9 minutes left. He didn't "have to take chances" at that point.
Right, there was no reason to throw deep into triple coverage with just under 2 minutes left and 1st and 10 on the 48. And he clearly had 2 easier open targets underneath. Take what the defense gives and live to play another down.
People keep saying this. Nick talked about it last night. He's as down on Carr as anyone (he likes Winston more), but he said there is no locker room issue there. Olave is not getting up for Winston and not for Carr. He said all the offensive players are behind Carr and like Carr.
Taymis Carr
You act like that would be his first start. He's already started a bunch of games and the INTs just keep coming. That's his entire career. What do you expect to find out?
Create an account or login to comment
You must be a member in order to leave a comment
Create account
Create an account on our community. It's easy!
Log in
Already have an account? Log in here.
